X has told an Indian court that the police orders demanding the removal of accounts belonging to two of India’s best-known free-speech organisations were not genuine. The disclosure came on Friday, days after the purported takedown requests set off a public outcry.
What X Told the Court?
According to X, the orders were submitted through its online reporting form in the name of a senior Delhi police officer. They asked the platform to block the accounts of the Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) and the Software Freedom Law Centre, India (SFLC.in), claiming the two groups had defamed the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). The RSS is the Hindu nationalist organisation from which Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party emerged.
A lawyer for X told the Delhi High Court that the company had carried out an internal investigation. His conclusion was blunt: the orders came from “somebody impersonating Delhi police.”
Delhi Police did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The Three-Hour Problem
One detail in this story deserves more attention than it has received. The purported orders invoked Indian rules that require platforms to act on such notices within three hours. X forwarded the notices to the affected users before it had established that they were fake.
In practice, that sequence matters. Platforms work under tight deadlines, and a convincing document that carries an official name can move through the system quickly. A notice does not have to be real to cause harm; it only has to look real long enough to be acted on.
Why the Orders Caused an Uproar?
IFF had asked the court to quash the orders. They triggered strong reactions on social media this week, with Amnesty and India’s main opposition party questioning their legality.
The background makes the reaction easy to understand. IFF and SFLC.in are known for publicising government blocking orders and challenging them in court. Free-speech activists have long argued that India’s strict content removal rules are used to curb dissent in the world’s most populous nation.
The government sees it differently. India, which has more than 1.1 billion internet subscribers, says its directives target unlawful or misleading content and respect lawful expression.
Legal Notices Sent to the Groups
The petition adds another layer. According to it, the two groups also received legal notices last week, purportedly on behalf of the RSS. Those notices demanded that they stop criticising and documenting government blocking orders.
What This Means?
Having covered technology and policy for a long time, I see two separate questions here. The first is who sent the fake orders and why. That is still unanswered, and nobody should assume the answer until the court process or an investigation provides it. The second is about systems: how a platform verifies takedown notices before passing them on, especially when the deadline is only three hours.
Both questions will matter well beyond this single case, because every platform operating in India faces the same rules and the same clock.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did X tell the Delhi High Court?
- X said the police orders seeking removal of the IFF and SFLC.in accounts were fake, and that someone had impersonated Delhi Police to send them.
Which groups were targeted?
- The Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) and the Software Freedom Law Centre, India (SFLC.in).
What did the fake orders claim?
- They claimed the two groups had defamed the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).
How were the orders sent to X?
- They were submitted through X’s online reporting form in the name of a senior Delhi police officer.
Why does the three-hour rule matter?
- The orders invoked rules that require platforms to act within three hours. X forwarded the notices to the affected users before establishing they were fake.
Has Delhi Police responded?
- Delhi Police did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


