The Supreme Court has sharply criticised civic authorities and the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) over the worsening pollution in the Yamuna. Its concern is simple. Large sums of money are being spent on cleaning the river, yet the water keeps getting dirtier.
On Monday, a bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan directed the CPCB to monitor water quality at the points where the river and its 520 drains enter and leave states, Union territories and districts. The court also made it clear that authorities will be held accountable if water quality gets worse within their area. The order is dated November 4, and the matter has been listed for further hearing on January 13.
“Everything That Is Wrong” Shows Up in the River
The bench did not hold back. It said everything that is wrong with the civic administration in towns, cities and villages along the river’s banks is reflected in the poor health of the Yamuna and in the 520 drains that discharge wastewater into it. This, the court said, is why pollution in the river has only increased despite huge spending on cleaning it.
Stop Pollution at the Source
The court said industrial pollutants and untreated sewage must be stopped at the source. It also observed that building more sewage treatment plants alone will not be enough to solve the problem.
Where pollution cannot be prevented at the source, the bench said, sewage must first be tapped and then treated. But it admitted that this is hard to do. Two problems stand in the way:
- Weak sewage networks in many towns and cities
- Stormwater and sewage drains joined together, which makes it difficult to separate and collect sewage
The court was especially frank about unauthorised colonies built on encroached land. It said it would be difficult, if not impossible, for civic authorities to tap sewage in most of these areas, because they were not built on a grid layout and have hardly any space for a sewage system.
States and Districts Face Penalties if Water Quality Falls
One of the most important directions concerns accountability. The court told the CPCB to track water quality at the entry and exit points of states, Union territories and districts. If the quality gets worse on any parameter while the river passes through a jurisdiction, the administration concerned will be held accountable and penalised.
Any compensation or fine will have to be deposited with the registry of the Supreme Court. The CPCB has been asked to propose a formula for calculating it.
Investigating Fish Deaths, Foam and Algal Blooms
The court also directed the CPCB to look into incidents that point to river pollution. These include:
- Fish deaths
- White foam on the surface
- Eutrophication or algal blooms
- Spikes in biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), chemical oxygen demand (COD) or total suspended solids (TSS)
The CPCB’s reports must identify the causes behind such incidents or rises in pollution and recommend remedial measures.
Wider Support and Access for the CPCB
To make sure the board can do its job, the bench gave several more directions:
- Central and state ministries, departments and agencies must give the CPCB and its experts administrative, technical, logistical and operational support.
- Public and private entities working in wastewater, solid waste and effluent treatment must give CPCB officials and designated third-party agencies unrestricted access to their premises, installations and records. This includes surprise inspections, sample collection, audits and checks of monitoring equipment.
- Plant operators and the authorities concerned must provide complete data access and cooperate in connecting their systems to the CPCB’s centralised monitoring network.
What Comes Next?
The January 13 hearing will show how far the CPCB has moved on monitoring and on the proposed formula for penalties. The bigger test is whether states and districts act before the penalties begin. For a river that has seen years of expensive clean-up plans, the court’s message is clear. Spending money is not the same as cleaning the water.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court say about the Yamuna?
- The court said pollution in the river has only increased despite huge sums being spent on cleaning it, and it blamed failures in civic administration along its banks.
Who heard the case?
- A bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan.
How many drains discharge wastewater into the Yamuna?
- The court referred to 520 drains.
What has the CPCB been asked to do?
- It must monitor water quality where the river and its drains enter and exit states, Union territories and districts, investigate pollution incidents, and propose a formula for calculating fines.
Who can be penalised?
- Any state, Union territory or district where water quality gets worse on any parameter while the river passes through it will be held accountable and penalised.
Where will the fines be paid?
- They will be deposited with the registry of the Supreme Court.
Why is sewage hard to tap in some areas?
- The court pointed to weak sewage networks, the mixing of stormwater and sewage drains, and unauthorised colonies on encroached land that have almost no space for sewage systems.
When is the next hearing?
- January 13.


