A sustainability nonprofit and two faith-based investors have gone to federal court to stop a Kentucky law that puts a warning label on certain kinds of investment advice.
Ceres, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR) and United Church Funds (UCF) filed their lawsuit last week in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky. They want a judge to strike down Senate Bill 183 and block the state from enforcing it. The defendant named in the case is Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman.
What Senate Bill 183 actually requires?
SB 183 passed in the state’s 2026 legislative session. It targets proxy advisers, the firms that help institutional investors decide how to vote on shareholder proposals and director nominations.
Under the law, any proxy advice that is “wholly or partly based on, or otherwise takes into account” nonpecuniary factors must carry a public disclosure. Nonpecuniary factors are considerations beyond direct financial return, including environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues. The disclosure must state that the advice “is not being provided solely in the interest of shareholders.”
The wording is the heart of the dispute. The law covers advice that is only partly based on such factors, and it treats that advice as not serving shareholders, whatever its financial reasoning.
A veto, then an override
Kentucky lawmakers passed the bill in March. Gov. Andy Beshear, a Democrat, vetoed it on March 27. He said he acted “at the request of faith-based organizations that believe it infringes on their First Amendment rights.”
The legislature overrode the veto on March 31, so the law stands.
The constitutional claims
The plaintiffs make two main arguments.
First Amendment. The complaint says SB 183 “regulates speech, explicitly discriminating based on viewpoint and content,” and forces covered speakers “to say things they don’t believe.” It describes the law as “aimed at suppressing ideas in the investment community.”
Fourteenth Amendment. The plaintiffs also say the law is unconstitutionally vague, so advisers cannot tell clearly which advice triggers the disclosure.
The complaint is also blunt about the law’s purpose. “Institutional investors do not need protection from the free flow of proxy-voting information,” it says. It argues that Kentucky’s General Assembly instead meant to make it harder for shareholders to challenge corporate leadership, and to suppress requests that companies address issues affecting long-term performance.
Who is behind the case?
ICCR is leading the suit. Ceres and UCF are plaintiffs alongside it. All three are represented by the litigation nonprofit Democracy Forward and the law firm Tachau Meek PLC.
In the group’s release, Democracy Forward President and CEO Skye Perryman said shareholders have a right to ask questions, challenge corporate leadership, and make investment decisions guided by their values and their understanding of long-term financial risk. ICCR CEO Josh Zinner said the law violates “fundamental First Amendment principles” and that a healthy economy depends on the free exchange of ideas.
Not the first challenge of its kind
Kentucky’s law is part of a wider push by states to regulate proxy advice. The earlier court challenges were brought by the two largest proxy advisers, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis, either together or separately. Over the past two years they have sued and stopped similar laws from taking effect in Texas, Kansas, Indiana and Oklahoma.
The Kentucky case differs in who is suing. This time the challenge comes from shareholders and advocacy groups rather than from the advisory firms themselves, and the plaintiffs frame the harm as a restriction on investors’ own ability to speak up and be advised.
What to watch next?
The first thing to watch is whether the court grants an injunction before the law is enforced. That is the step that kept the Texas, Kansas, Indiana and Oklahoma laws from taking effect. How the Attorney General’s office responds will also show how Kentucky plans to defend the law.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Kentucky Senate Bill 183?
- It is a 2026 state law that requires proxy advisers to publish a disclosure when their advice takes nonpecuniary factors, such as ESG issues, into account. The disclosure must say the advice is not provided solely in the interest of shareholders.
Who is suing Kentucky over the law?
- Ceres, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility and United Church Funds. They are represented by Democracy Forward and Tachau Meek PLC.
What do the plaintiffs say is wrong with the law?
- They argue that it violates the First Amendment by compelling speech and discriminating based on viewpoint. They also say it violates the Fourteenth Amendment because it is unconstitutionally vague.
Did the governor support the law?
- No. Gov. Andy Beshear vetoed it on March 27, citing First Amendment concerns raised by faith-based organizations. The legislature overrode the veto on March 31.
Have other states passed similar laws?
- Yes. ISS and Glass Lewis have challenged comparable laws in Texas, Kansas, Indiana and Oklahoma and stopped them from taking effect.


