MISO’s Large Load Study Plan Faces Pushback from States and Clean Energy Advocates

Parth Patel
By
Parth Patel
With 7+ years of experience in journalism and content research, this author brings a detail-oriented approach to news reporting. He focuses on investigating developments, verifying information,...
8 Min Read

A proposal from the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO) to speed up the pairing of big power users with new generation is drawing heavy resistance at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). Clean energy trade groups, ratepayer advocates and 11 of the 15 states in MISO’s territory urged the commission on Friday to reject it.

Their objections are mostly about two things. They say the plan does too little to stop costs from landing on existing customers. Several also argue it favors vertically integrated utilities over independent power producers. A number of utilities, including Duke Energy Indiana and the Entergy companies, have told FERC to approve it.

 

What MISO is proposing?

The plan is called the Large Load Addition Resource Study, or LARS. It is a 120-day process that would study a large new load and the generation meant to serve it at the same time, rather than in separate tracks.

Eligibility is limited. The process would be open to loads above 200 MW, paired with generation in the same local resource zone. MISO has 10 such zones, and they broadly follow state lines.

MISO filed the proposal earlier this month, partly in response to FERC. In mid-June, the commission found that MISO’s existing rules for large loads were inadequate, including for connecting “proximate” loads and generation to the grid, according to the grid operator’s own application.

 

States raise cost-shifting and competition concerns

The Organization of MISO States (OMS) told FERC that a majority of its members hold “significant concerns.” Those include a lack of safeguards against shifting transmission costs onto existing customers. They also include possible effects on competition and on MISO’s generator interconnection queue.

OMS was direct about where it draws the line. LARS, it said, should not turn into a general alternative to the regular interconnection queue or a route to preferential transmission access without proper protections for existing queue participants and transmission customers. It also said any LARS-style program should end after five years.

Eleven state utility commissions backed those comments. The picture was not unanimous, though. Commissions in Arkansas, Louisiana and Mississippi voted against the critical comments and filed their own letters at FERC supporting MISO’s plan.

 

Google and environmental groups warn about who pays

In separate filings, Google and a coalition that includes the Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defense Council made a similar point: existing customers could end up paying for the network upgrades that new loads and generation require.

Google’s filing is notable because it is a likely user of such a process. The company said that, whatever speed-to-power benefits LARS offers, the way it is built threatens Google’s commitment that other retail customers will not bear the cost of serving its data centers. It pointed to its Ratepayer Protection Pledge in making that case.

MISO has said it will file a cost allocation framework for LARS projects next month. Google argued that this leaves a gap, since the details and the strength of its protections against cost shifts are still open questions that FERC “cannot simply assume away.” Ratepayer advocates from six states also opposed the proposal, with cost shifting among their concerns.

 

Independent producers say the process is rigged against them

The second major objection is about access. Under the proposal, MISO would accept LARS applications only from its transmission customers. In practice, that means load-serving entities (LSEs), which in MISO are mostly vertically integrated utilities.

The American Clean Power Association (ACP) and other groups said this would let utilities favor their own generation over that of independent power producers (IPPs). In a joint filing, ACP and the Southern Renewable Energy Association noted that even an IPP holding a direct offtake agreement with the large customer must be sponsored by the LSE’s application. There is no way for an IPP to deal with MISO directly to reach the interconnection queue. The trade groups added that even if an LSE agrees to include an IPP, the IPP would face stricter eligibility requirements than utility-owned generation.

The Solar Energy Industries Association and Advanced Energy United asked FERC to reject the plan outright. They called it unduly discriminatory because it lets LSEs decide whether their competitors can take part.

Even the Data Center Coalition, which generally supported the proposal, flagged a concern. In a mostly vertically integrated region, it said, making the LSE the only gateway narrows the supply that can reach expedited Large Load Generation Interconnection Agreements to projects the LSE has effectively approved.

 

Utilities defend the plan

MISO’s transmission owners see it differently. In a joint filing, they described LARS as a narrowly tailored but valuable tool for quickly evaluating electrically close load and generation pairs and for identifying more efficient network upgrades.

They also argued that making LARS permanent would send a long-term market signal for pairing large loads with new generation for at least 15 years. Entergy and Cleco Power urged FERC to approve it. In a joint filing, they said permanence gives developers the regulatory and financial certainty needed to site and finance such pairings, and that the process still has built-in limits that keep each cycle bounded.

 

What to watch next?

FERC now has a divided record to weigh. The decision may turn on two things: whether MISO’s cost allocation filing next month answers the cost-shifting worries, and whether the commission is persuaded that utility-sponsored access is a fair design. The outcome will matter well beyond MISO, since many grid operators are working through how to connect large loads, especially data centers, without raising costs for everyone else.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is MISO’s LARS proposal?

  • LARS, or the Large Load Addition Resource Study, is a proposed 120-day process that studies a large load and nearby generation together. It is open to loads above 200 MW paired with generation in the same local resource zone.

Why are states and clean energy groups opposing it?

  • Critics say it lacks enough protection against costs shifting to existing customers, and that it could disadvantage independent power producers because only utilities can apply.

Who supports the proposal?

  • Duke Energy Indiana, the Entergy utilities, Cleco Power and a group of MISO transmission owners back it. Arkansas, Louisiana and Mississippi regulators also filed in support. The Data Center Coalition generally supports it but wants wider access.

What does OMS want changed?

  • OMS wants stronger safeguards for existing customers and queue participants, and it says any LARS-like program should end after five years.

What happens next?

  • FERC will decide whether to approve, reject or require changes. MISO is also expected to file a cost allocation framework for LARS projects next month.
Share This Article
With 7+ years of experience in journalism and content research, this author brings a detail-oriented approach to news reporting. He focuses on investigating developments, verifying information, and presenting complex stories in a clear and accessible manner.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *